Welcome to Myth-Busting Monday on The Vet Vortex, where we grab the mop, clean up the myths, and leave only sparkling science behind. Today, we’re diving (pun absolutely intended) into one of the most slippery debates in animal science:
Do fish actually feel pain?
You’ve probably heard all kinds of opinions - from “Fish don’t have feelings” to “They forget everything in three seconds.” (Spoiler: they don’t.)
Let’s wade in gently, so we don’t spook the goldfish.
What Is Pain, Anyway?
Most people think pain is just that sharp “Ouch!” moment when you touch something hot or stub your toe. But scientifically, pain is far more layered than that. It’s not just a single event - it’s a conversation happening inside your body between nerves, your brain, and your emotions.
Think of it this way:
Pain starts as an alarm signal - your body’s built-in “Danger, danger!” siren. When tissue gets damaged or threatened, special sensory nerves called nociceptors pick up that signal. They send a quick message through the spinal cord to the brain that says, “Hey, something’s wrong down here!”
Now, the brain has a choice:
- It can simply register that signal and trigger a reflex (like yanking your hand off a hot stove).
- Or it can interpret that signal - giving it emotional context: That hurt! I don’t want to do that again.
That second part - the emotional, conscious awareness, is what we usually associate with the word “pain.”
So, pain isn’t just about the physical injury; it’s also about how your brain feels, labels, and remembers that experience.
In animals, and especially fish, scientists look for both of those parts:
- The physical detection (nociception) - do they sense damage?
- The emotional perception (pain) - do they experience and respond to it in a meaningful way?
Why does this matter? Because understanding the difference helps us treat animals (and fish!) with the respect they deserve - recognizing that just because they don’t scream doesn’t mean they don’t feel.
In essence, pain is more than a symptom - it’s a survival tool. It teaches all creatures, great and small, what to avoid next time.
The Big Question: Can Fish Feel Pain?
Fish do feel pain.
The real question scientists have wrestled with for decades is: Do they consciously feel it like we or our dogs do?
They’ve got the hardware (nociceptors) but not the emotional processing unit (the neocortex). Think of it like a phone with great sensors but no selfie camera. It still detects; it just doesn’t emote.
So, while a fish might not “suffer” the way we picture it, it certainly feels and reacts to pain. And that’s more than just reflex.
The Science of Aquatic Pain
Picture this: your goldfish glides gracefully through its tank like a little underwater ballerina… until it brushes against a jagged decoration or swims through a patch of water that’s turned slightly toxic from high ammonia levels. Ouch. That, right there, is where the story of pain begins.
When a fish encounters something harmful - a sharp object, poor water quality, or even a fishing hook, tiny alarm systems under its skin called nociceptors spring into action.
These little sentinels live in the skin, fins, mouth, and gills, always on guard for anything that screams “danger!” or “damage!”
Once those nociceptors detect trouble, they send an electrical signal racing along nerve fibers - the fish’s version of a lightning-fast text alert.
That signal zips through the spinal cord, heads up to the brainstem, and finally reaches the forebrain, where the message gets sorted out.
Here’s where it gets fascinating: fish don’t have a neocortex, the part of the human brain responsible for conscious thought and emotion. So for a long time, scientists assumed that meant fish couldn’t feel pain - at least, not the way mammals do.
But research says otherwise. Fish have a brain region called the pallium, which handles sensory and emotional processing much like the neocortex does in humans. Think of it as a different operating system running a similar app.
So while a fish might not ponder pain (“why does this always happen to me?”), it absolutely registers discomfort and reacts to it in meaningful ways.
A fish in pain isn’t just a reflex machine. It changes its behavior:
- It might rub its sore area against rocks or tank walls.
- It could hide, move less, or swim differently.
- It might avoid certain spots or refuse food.
Those aren’t random reflexes, they’re signs of awareness, a clear “this hurts and I want it to stop.” In scientific terms, that’s behavioral adaptation, not just knee-jerk response.
So yes, fish feel discomfort and modify their behavior to avoid it.
That’s not a reflex. That’s awareness.
How We Know: The Science Behind the Splash
Back in the early 2000s, a scientist named Dr. Lynne Sneddon (a name every fish lover should know) conducted landmark studies showing that rainbow trout had pain receptors in their faces and changed their behavior when exposed to mildly painful substances.
When given painkillers like morphine?
Their behavior went back to normal.
That’s pretty solid evidence that they’re not just reacting automatically - they’re processing discomfort in some way.
And that’s not just trout. Studies in zebrafish, goldfish, carp, and even sharks show similar results. Some stop eating. Some rub injured areas on tank surfaces. Others hide or act differently for days.
If that’s not “something hurts,” I don’t know what is.
Why It Happens: The Evolutionary Logic
Pain isn’t a moral punishment. It’s a biological survival alarm.
If something hurts, an animal learns to avoid it - increasing its chances of survival. Fish evolved pain perception not because they wanted to suffer, but because it keeps them alive.
In the wild:
- A fish that feels “pain” from polluted water swims away.
- One that feels discomfort after a predator attack learns to avoid certain territories.
Without that sensory alarm, survival would be a guessing game.
Tito the Betta Fish
Let me tell you about Tito, a betta fish I once had in vet school. Tito was the picture of aquatic sass - flaring fins, strutting (yes, strutting) around his bowl like he owned the place.
One day, he got a fin tear - probably from an overly decorative plastic plant (rookie mistake). Suddenly, my little drama king wouldn’t eat, wouldn’t swim much, and kept hovering near the bottom. His color even dulled.
After some gentle tank TLC, a change to silk plants, and a few drops of aquarium salt, he perked right back up.
If I didn’t know better, I’d say he looked relieved.
Just like Dr. Lynne Sneddon’s trout, that moment changed me. Tito proved in his own finned way that fish don’t just react - they feel.
It reminded me that pain looks different in every species - but it’s still pain.
Why This Myth Persists
Why do so many people believe fish can’t feel pain?
Because fish are different. They don’t have facial muscles to frown. They don’t cry or whimper. They don’t limp dramatically like dogs.
Their communication is subtle - a shift in movement, a flick of the fins, a change in color or appetite.
And because we humans tend to equate “pain” with “visible suffering,” we’ve been underestimating them for centuries.
What Pet Parents Can Do
If you’ve got a scaly little roommate gliding around your aquarium, here’s how to keep them healthy, happy, and blissfully pain-free.
Poor water = poor life.
Fish don’t just live in water - they breathe it, drink it, and absorb it through their gills and skin. So when the water’s off, everything else goes downhill fast.
- Test your tank weekly for ammonia, nitrite, nitrate, and pH.
- Do regular partial water changes (about 20 - 30% each week).
- Always use dechlorinated, temperature-matched water - sudden changes can shock their system.
Think of it like this: clean water to a fish is what clean air is to us. You wouldn’t want to live in smog, right?
Skip the sharp stuff! Jagged rocks, harsh gravel, and cheap plastic plants can slice fins and cause infections. Go for smooth ornaments, live plants, or silk decorations instead. Your fish will thank you with stress-free fins and confident swims.
Fish are small, but their appetites can trick you. Overfeeding is the number one cause of stress (and yes, pain!) in aquariums. Uneaten food decomposes, releasing ammonia that burns their gills.
Feed tiny, measured portions once or twice a day, just what they can finish in under two minutes. In this case, less truly is more.
Pain in fish doesn’t look like human pain - no yelps or limps here. Instead, watch for the quiet signals:
- Clamped fins
- Gasping at the surface
- Loss of appetite
- Rubbing against tank surfaces
- Dull coloration or hiding more than usual
You don’t need a degree to notice when something’s “off.” A few minutes of observation each day can make all the difference.
If you must catch or move your fish, use a soft, fine-mesh net and avoid temperature shocks. Move calmly - rough handling feels to them like a full-body slam in slow motion.
And if your fish ever needs a medical procedure, remember this: fish can be sedated safely by a vet. A little anesthesia goes a long way in preventing pain and trauma.
Fish may not scream, but they absolutely signal. Once you learn their language - their color shifts, fin posture, or swim patterns. You’ll never miss when something’s wrong again.
Because when it comes to fish, silence doesn’t mean comfort - it just means you haven’t learned the dialect yet.
What Vets Can Do
Fish medicine has officially entered its glow-up era, and trust me, it’s swimming in sophistication. Gone are the days when a fish with fin rot or a buoyancy issue was written off as “just unlucky.” Today’s aquatic vets treat fish with the same compassion, precision, and pain management we’d offer any cat, dog, or parrot.
Here’s what modern veterinary care looks like beneath the surface:
- Sedation with Science:
- Pain Management that Works:
- Diagnostics on Another Level:
- Treat Infections and Injuries
Even small tweaks - a cleaner filter, balanced pH, or better diet, can turn recovery from sluggish to spectacular.
- Healing the Right Way:
- Education and Empathy:
In short: modern veterinary medicine now takes fish welfare seriously and with every tiny X-ray, every drop of anesthetic, and every conversation with a curious pet parent, we’re proving that compassion knows no species.
- Collaborate With Aquatic Specialists
In short: modern veterinary medicine takes fish welfare seriously. We’ve traded the old “they’re just fish” mindset for a future where every fin counts, and the water’s never been clearer.
Treatment
If a fish is injured or ill:
- Treat infections promptly (antibacterial or antifungal water treatments).
- Correct water chemistry immediately.
- Use aquarium salts to soothe mild skin irritations or fin tears.
- Consult an aquatic vet for proper pain relief - never self-dose with human medications.
Prognosis
When identified early and handled gently, most cases of fish discomfort or pain have an excellent prognosis.
Fish can regenerate fins, recover from mild trauma, and even bounce back from stress-related conditions if the environment improves.
But chronic stress or untreated injuries? Those lead to immune suppression, infections, and early death.
Prevention
Pain prevention starts with good husbandry:
- Cycle your tank before adding fish.
- Avoid overcrowding.
- Quarantine new fish to prevent infections and aggression.
- Maintain a consistent environment. Fish hate surprises more than cats hate baths.
Zoonotic Implications
Fish pain itself isn’t contagious (thankfully), but fish diseases can be.
- Some species carry Mycobacterium marinum (“fish handler’s disease”), which can infect open human wounds.
- Poor aquarium hygiene can also harbor pathogens like Aeromonas and Vibrio.
So:
- Always wash hands after handling fish or water.
- Avoid touching your face or open cuts.
- Use separate equipment for each tank.
Healthy fish = happy humans.
But let’s be honest - we can’t just drop the “fish feel pain” truth bomb and swim away. We owe it to them to talk about what that means for their welfare.
Beyond the Myths: What Fish Pain Means for Fish Welfare
So, now that we’ve established that fish do feel pain, the next big question is - what do we do with that knowledge?
Because knowing fish can suffer means we have a moral and medical responsibility to rethink how we treat them - in tanks, in labs, and even on dinner plates.
Let’s talk about what fish welfare really means in light of what we now understand about their capacity for pain.
What Is Fish Welfare, Really?
Fish welfare isn’t just about keeping them alive.
It’s about ensuring they can thrive.
The modern definition of animal welfare includes three overlapping pillars:
- Physical well-being - absence of disease, injury, or chronic pain.
- Psychological well-being - ability to perform natural behaviors and avoid prolonged stress.
- Environmental well-being - clean, stable, enriching surroundings that support health.
Fish might not wag tails or purr, but they show welfare cues through behavior, color, feeding patterns, and social interaction.
A brightly colored, curious fish that explores its tank is thriving.
A pale, hiding fish with clamped fins is not.
Simple, yet profound.
Why Fish Welfare Matters
Here’s the thing - fish aren’t a niche group. They’re the most abundant vertebrates on Earth.
They make up more than half of all animal species with backbones.
Yet, for decades, they’ve been the forgotten frontier of animal welfare.
Why? Because they’re quiet. No barking, no crying, no bleeding in ways we recognize.
But now that science confirms they can feel pain, the ethical equation changes:
If a creature can suffer, it deserves protection from unnecessary suffering.
That’s not sentimentality - that’s science plus empathy.
In Aquariums: Rethinking “Low Maintenance”
Let’s be honest - fish are often bought as “starter pets.”
But that’s where welfare often goes sideways.
Poor water conditions, tiny bowls, uncycled tanks, and decorative torture chambers (yes, I’m looking at you, sharp-edged castles) create constant low-grade pain and stress.
Chronic stress in fish isn’t just an emotional burden - it’s biological warfare. It leads to:
- Immune suppression
- Fin rot and infections
- Ulceration
- Reduced lifespan
Fish welfare starts with environmental respect.
A well-maintained aquarium is not just a pretty glass box - it’s a microcosm of nature, and every little detail matters.
As I always tell clients: If you wouldn’t live in it, don’t make your fish live in it either.
In Aquaculture: Welfare Scales Up
Now let’s zoom out - beyond living rooms to the fish farms that feed billions.
Fish raised for food are often handled, transported, and slaughtered under conditions that would never be accepted for mammals or birds, partly because people assume “they don’t feel it.”
But research says otherwise:
Crowding, poor oxygenation, rough handling, and dry air exposure all cause measurable stress and pain responses in fish.
Forward-thinking aquaculture systems are changing this - using humane stunning methods, enriched habitats, and species-specific welfare guidelines.
Because stress-free fish don’t just live better - they taste better. (Yes, even welfare has flavor.)
For Vets: Expanding the Circle of Care
Veterinarians play a crucial role in advancing fish welfare.
We must:
- Recognize pain in species-specific ways.
- Advocate for proper analgesia and anesthesia during handling or procedures.
- Educate clients that fish deserve medical attention just like cats or dogs.
Fish medicine isn’t fringe anymore. It’s a rapidly growing specialty and it’s reshaping how we view aquatic sentience.
When we extend veterinary compassion to fish, we elevate the entire field.
The Emotional Side: Compassion Underwater
Acknowledging fish pain isn’t about guilt-tripping pet parents or farmers.
It’s about empathy.
It’s about realizing that intelligence and suffering don’t look the same in every species.
Fish may not think like us, but they feel enough to deserve consideration.
They remember, they learn, they bond, and yes - they hurt.
That awareness changes everything.
The Future of Fish Welfare
Here’s where it gets exciting. The next decade will see:
- AI-powered behavior monitoring to detect pain or distress early.
- Welfare certification for ornamental and food fish.
- Better anesthesia and analgesia protocols.
- Increased public education about responsible fishkeeping.
The shift is already happening - from “fish as decoration” to “fish as patients.”
And we, as vets and pet parents, are at the heart of that movement.
The Bigger Picture
Acknowledging that fish feel pain doesn’t mean we can’t eat them or keep them - it just means we owe them respectful care.
It means better aquaculture standards.
It means teaching kids that “just a goldfish” is still a living, feeling creature.
When we understand the quiet ways animals experience the world, we grow - as scientists, as vets, and as humans.
In Closing
So… can fish feel pain?
Absolutely, just because they don’t scream doesn’t mean they don’t hurt.
Science has already handed us the proof. But compassion? That’s the part we write ourselves - in how gently we feed, house, and handle these quiet, glimmering beings.
Fish welfare isn’t some fancy upgrade for “serious” hobbyists. It’s a moral evolution - the next ripple in our journey toward a kinder coexistence with all creatures, gills and all.
So the next time you gaze into your aquarium, don’t just see decorations or darting fins. See a living world of silent sensations - a small, shimmering universe that depends on you to make it humane.
Because empathy doesn’t need gills to breathe.
And that ripple you see in the water? It’s a reflection of how far we’ve come… and how much deeper we can still go.
Your Turn
What about you, have you ever noticed your fish reacting to changes in their tank or to you standing nearby?
If you’ve got a finned friend at home, observe them this week.
Notice how they act when they’re happy, hungry, or shy.
That’s how you start to understand their language - one ripple at a time.
And if you ever catch yourself wondering, “Is my fish okay?”, don’t shrug it off. Ask your vet. Ask me. That’s what The Vet Vortex is here for.
Share your thoughts in the comments or tag us on social media @TheVetVortex with your stories - we’d love to hear how you’re making waves in fish welfare!
Until next time, keep swimming in compassion.
Stay curious. Stay compassionate. Stay vortexy.
Check out previous post - Fall Exercise: Keeping Dogs Active as Temperatures Drop